Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David's avatar

I think the whole carbon conversation is a distraction, because all industrial farming practices (even of organic carrots), are heavy carbon producers, and industrially produced organic vegetables require CAFOs to supply the nitrogen in their compost at an affordable scale (organic tillage ag requires copious amounts of compost - very heavy and resource intense to apply - as well as depending on CAFOs for their cheap nitrogen supply stream) .

The bedrock of the justification for the perpetuation of industrial farming system is the wholesale deification of the green revolution. In Ag schools at land grant universities, among USDA extension agents, or among mainline agronomists, the orthodoxy of the green revolution cannot be questioned.

Norman Borlaug, a plant pathologist, is hailed as one of the central people to the green revolution, working with money from the Rockefeller and Ford foundations (shudder) to develop a hybridized wheat variety that produced higher yields and had lower disease pressure. This system did require the use of high amounts of pesticides and synthetic fertilizer to function properly. (I think productive varieties are a good thing, but productive varieties that require chemical inputs ensure the indebtedness of the farmer). Borlaug is famous for supporting DDT use long after it had been rejected by the public as overly toxic.

Although the green revolution is usually said to have taken place in the 1960s, much of the theoretical foundations were laid in the late 19th and early 20th century. Bosch extracting nitrogen from the atmosphere through CH4, and the development of various herbicides and pesticides. I have heard multiple accounts how polio’s symptoms were caused by synthetic pesticides that were introduced early in the 20th century.

Borlaug is hailed as the savior of the world, preventing 1-2 billion people from starving. And while I do think intensive agricultural production is preferable to non-intensive ag production (yield per acre is an important metric but not the important metric), the logic of the green revolution forces us to accept the whole soup of industrial farming practices instead of picking and choosing ones based on current scientific understanding of agronomy, biology and human health. And I can’t help but see the connection in ownership between ag chemical companies, large packaged food conglomerates and pharmaceutical companies. These form the chemical cartel, the owners of molecules that drive the modern world, and which for the most part are based on a faulty assumption: that we can reduce biological complexity to chemical simplicity. This is the theoretical foundation of the green revolution and it has yielded productive fruit, but at a grave cost to us all. Let us reevaluate the entire project, because there are turtles all the way down.

Expand full comment
Fritz Freud's avatar

There is only one way to fight back: General Strike.

#GeneralStrike: Why we all must Support #Farmers & #Truckers

Bring Down the Government and hold them Accountable

https://fritzfreud.substack.com/p/generalstrike-why-we-all-must-support

Citizen Uprising: Lock Down all Politicians

Citizen House Arrest all Politicians on presumption of Treason and Corruption

https://fritzfreud.substack.com/p/citizen-uprising-lock-down-all-politicians

A Month of Revenge (Blueprint for a Revolution)

A white paper outlying a swift plan to end their plans forever

https://fritzfreud.substack.com/p/a-month-of-revenge-blueprint-for

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts